This is my all-time favorite concealer. I started using it about 5 years ago, and used to buy it from Ulta. The Ulta locations near me eventually stopped carrying this specific product in their stores. So, I tried buying it on Amazon, but the product I received from them was not even close to being the same. It was oily and had some kind of gritty substance mixed into it. Then I realized I could buy direct from Amazing Cosmetics on this website, so I ordered it here, and it is the same amazing product I used to buy at Ulta. I'm so happy they are selling direct now! This concealer is thick, and a little goes a long way. But it does not cake-up or change colors (oxidize) after applying. Love it!